Malaysia’s voter revolt continues

By Ooi Kee Beng

AUG 28 — In gaining a substantially bigger victory margin than his wife Datuk Seri Dr Wan Azizah Ismail did in the March 8 general election (15,671 votes to 13,398), Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim’s coalition continues its march towards federal power.

The former deputy prime minister and former finance minister managed to secure 67 per cent of votes cast in the pivotal by-election held on Tuesday in his home base of Permatang Pauh in Penang. The turnout of 81.01 per cent was surprisingly high, given the fact that it rained heavily in the area that day. This allayed fears that voters would stay away because of tension on the streets.

Declaring his triumph a landslide, the de facto leader of the opposition in Malaysia returns to Parliament after 10 trying years.

As a people’s representative in the august House, Anwar will be better able to convince fence-sitters in the governing coalition, the Barisan Nasional, that his Pakatan Rakyat opposition alliance is worth crossing over to. His sights seem to be set on the East Malaysian states where he is taking advantage of dissatisfaction among BN component parties over what they see as haughty treatment towards them by the federal government on the peninsula.

Anwar’s choice of Sept 16 as the day on which he will move against the government is therefore done largely for symbolic reasons. That was the day 45 years ago when the East Malaysian states of Sabah and Sarawak, along with Singapore, joined Malaya to form Malaysia.

With the stakes being as high as they are now, Anwar’s victory holds great significance for the immediate stability of the country.

Permatang Pauh represents the first occasion after the March 8 elections that voters have had to express any regret they may have had about voting so strongly against the government. The increased margin for Anwar shows that voters have no regrets, and are in fact continuing their revolt against the federal government.

This means that the pressure on Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi’s administration increases further. His schedule to stay in power until mid-2010 — which has locked his deputy, Datuk Seri Najib Abdul Razak, into a continued position of loyalty — looks less likely to be entertained by his dominant party, Umno, in the coming months.

Furthermore, the fact that Najib was so strongly involved in leading the campaign against Anwar makes the BN’s defeat a personal one for him. The loser in this by-election is not Umno’s candidate, state assemblyman Datuk Arif Shah Omar Shah. It is instead the Abdullah-Najib team. They will now have to answer to the party.

With the Malay ground more split than it was on March 8, over questions of swearing on the Quran, rising prices and multiracialism, Umno division heads will find it harder to stay quietly loyal to a leadership that is dismally failing to stop the biggest challenge to the party in its history. Putting changes on hold, as Abdullah’s retirement schedule seems to aim at doing, will satisfy Umno’s many warlords even less after the opposition’s latest success.

The government is not being accused of having done nothing though. It is commonly alleged to be behind the sodomy charge against Anwar, for example. In fact, it was this factor that forced Anwar’s hand. In response to it, his wife resigned as a Member of Parliament for Permatang Pauh, forcing the government to call the by-election.

Since then, the alleged “victim” of the sodomy, Anwar’s former aide Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan, has sworn on the Quran that all he had said was true. More surprisingly, Najib, the target of rumours claiming he was involved in the murder of a Mongolian woman, also went through a similar controversial ritual.

Anwar’s refusal to do likewise and swear that he had not committed sodomy seemed at first to hurt his standing among Malay voters. However, the huge support he received in the polls shows that the BN’s initiative actually backfired. Bringing religious rituals into the basically secular business of voting did not go down well with the electorate.

The sodomy trial is set for Sept 10 though, and Anwar will have to appear in court on that day. His camp is worried for his safety, and will do all it can to keep him from being detained.

Besides this serious legal hurdle, Anwar has to contend with an administrative impediment suddenly put in place by Abdullah. The Prime Minister is presenting the annual budget at a surprisingly early time tomorrow. This reschedule includes Parliament going into immediate recess thereafter, to reconvene only on Oct 13, after the fasting month and subsequent open houses.

Any plans by Anwar to make a dramatic move in Parliament on Sept 16, for example through a no-confidence motion against the government, is therefore quashed. Abdullah is aware, as is Anwar, that in politics, forcing a plan to be postponed increases the likelihood of it being discarded completely.

The confrontation between the two coalitions is coming to a head, and as recent events in Malaysian politics show, we cannot but continue to expect the unexpected. — TODAY

High voter turnout a blessing for Anwar

Commentary by Wan Hamidi Hamid

AUG 26 Some 48 per cent of the 58,459 voters have cast their votes by noon today and the Election Commission is expecting a high turnout of' 80 per cent for the Permatang Pauh by-election, almost similar to the turnout at the March 8 general election.

Observers note that a high turnout will favour Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim as a by-election usually attracts fewer voters due to the fact that many people think one seat will not change the equation of the government.

The Penang state government has declared today a public holiday to encourage voter turnout but Barisan Nasional leaders have lambasted the move as being politically motivated to ensure Anwar's victory.

The Parti Keadilan Rakyat de facto leader is contesting the seat vacated by his wife Datuk Seri Dr Wan Azizah Ismail who won by a 13,398-vote majority with an 81.2 per cent turnout on March 8.

The weather was fine throughout the whole morning but by 12.45pm it started raining, as predicted by the Meteorological Department.

But as early as 11am, some 50 per cent of voters at Sekolah Kebangsaan Permatang Pauh had cast their votes. Pas vice-president Datuk Husam Musa, who was met by the press outside the school compound, was happy with the high turnout. He and other Pas leaders have been campaigning for Anwar since the Aug 16 nomination day.

Many opposition Pakatan Rakyat supporters are hoping for a bigger majority, up to 20,000, despite BN candidate Datuk Arif Shah Omar Shah's confidence that he can still make it, winning by a small margin.

The excitement among voters is an indication the political tsunami that swept Penang in the recent elections is likely to be repeated here. Even if the expected heavy rain dampens the effort of some late voters, the votes are expected to go Anwar's way.

And even if Anwar fails to win with a bigger majority, he is likely to win. The only problem for him later is if BN leaders pick on particular points.

It is because of this that PKR campaigners, with the help of their Pakatan partners Pas and DAP, have been working day and night for the past nine days to ensure a bigger majority.

His ally DAP veteran Lim Kit Siang too hopes for a bigger majority.

"As I said in two eve-of-polling ceramahs last night, there is no doubt of Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim being re-elected as MP for Permatang Pauh and his return to Parliament after an absence of a decade.

"The only question is Anwar's majority. I will not be satisfied unless it is an even bigger majority than Datuk Seri Dr Wan Azizah Ismail's 13,398-vote majority in the March 8 "political tsunami" to trigger a mini political tsunami in Malaysia by itself," he wrote in his blog today.

It's a tough but for Anwar, Permatang Pauh is his "kubu" (fortress).

The former deputy prime minister first won the parliamentary seat when he defeated Pas incumbent Zabidi Ali with a majority of 14,352 votes in 1982. He repeated his feat by beating Pas's Mohamad Sabu with a 10,479-vote majority in 1986, and Pas's Mahfuz Omar by 16,150 votes in 1990.

By 1995, even Pas had given up the contest. Anwar won with a thumping majority of 23,515 votes, defeating DAP's Abdul Rahman Manap.

After his sacking from the government and subsequent jailing by former mentor Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad in 1998, the general election a year later proved that the people's support for him was strong. His wife Wan Azizah won with a majority of 9,077 votes, defeating Anwar's former Umno strongman in Penang Datuk Dr Ibrahim Saad.

The failure of PKR to reinvent itself by 2004 however almost cost Wan Azizah her seat when she only managed to win by 590 votes, defeating a former National Mosque imam Datuk Pirdaus Abdullah. The recent political tsunami however brought Wan Azizah and her party back into the limelight.

The expected 80 per cent voter turnout may come through for him as those who have decided to choose Anwar continue to throng polling centres this afternoon amidst heavy rain. After all, many of them have shown a similar fighting spirit throughout the nightly ceramahs despite the downpours.

Voting ends today at 5pm and results are expected as early as 7pm.

High voter turnout a blessing for Anwar

Commentary by Wan Hamidi Hamid

AUG 26 Some 48 per cent of the 58,459 voters have cast their votes by noon today and the Election Commission is expecting a high turnout of' 80 per cent for the Permatang Pauh by-election, almost similar to the turnout at the March 8 general election.

Observers note that a high turnout will favour Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim as a by-election usually attracts fewer voters due to the fact that many people think one seat will not change the equation of the government.

The Penang state government has declared today a public holiday to encourage voter turnout but Barisan Nasional leaders have lambasted the move as being politically motivated to ensure Anwar's victory.

The Parti Keadilan Rakyat de facto leader is contesting the seat vacated by his wife Datuk Seri Dr Wan Azizah Ismail who won by a 13,398-vote majority with an 81.2 per cent turnout on March 8.

The weather was fine throughout the whole morning but by 12.45pm it started raining, as predicted by the Meteorological Department.

But as early as 11am, some 50 per cent of voters at Sekolah Kebangsaan Permatang Pauh had cast their votes. Pas vice-president Datuk Husam Musa, who was met by the press outside the school compound, was happy with the high turnout. He and other Pas leaders have been campaigning for Anwar since the Aug 16 nomination day.

Many opposition Pakatan Rakyat supporters are hoping for a bigger majority, up to 20,000, despite BN candidate Datuk Arif Shah Omar Shah's confidence that he can still make it, winning by a small margin.

The excitement among voters is an indication the political tsunami that swept Penang in the recent elections is likely to be repeated here. Even if the expected heavy rain dampens the effort of some late voters, the votes are expected to go Anwar's way.

And even if Anwar fails to win with a bigger majority, he is likely to win. The only problem for him later is if BN leaders pick on particular points.

It is because of this that PKR campaigners, with the help of their Pakatan partners Pas and DAP, have been working day and night for the past nine days to ensure a bigger majority.

His ally DAP veteran Lim Kit Siang too hopes for a bigger majority.

"As I said in two eve-of-polling ceramahs last night, there is no doubt of Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim being re-elected as MP for Permatang Pauh and his return to Parliament after an absence of a decade.

"The only question is Anwar's majority. I will not be satisfied unless it is an even bigger majority than Datuk Seri Dr Wan Azizah Ismail's 13,398-vote majority in the March 8 "political tsunami" to trigger a mini political tsunami in Malaysia by itself," he wrote in his blog today.

It's a tough but for Anwar, Permatang Pauh is his "kubu" (fortress).

The former deputy prime minister first won the parliamentary seat when he defeated Pas incumbent Zabidi Ali with a majority of 14,352 votes in 1982. He repeated his feat by beating Pas's Mohamad Sabu with a 10,479-vote majority in 1986, and Pas's Mahfuz Omar by 16,150 votes in 1990.

By 1995, even Pas had given up the contest. Anwar won with a thumping majority of 23,515 votes, defeating DAP's Abdul Rahman Manap.

After his sacking from the government and subsequent jailing by former mentor Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad in 1998, the general election a year later proved that the people's support for him was strong. His wife Wan Azizah won with a majority of 9,077 votes, defeating Anwar's former Umno strongman in Penang Datuk Dr Ibrahim Saad.

The failure of PKR to reinvent itself by 2004 however almost cost Wan Azizah her seat when she only managed to win by 590 votes, defeating a former National Mosque imam Datuk Pirdaus Abdullah. The recent political tsunami however brought Wan Azizah and her party back into the limelight.

The expected 80 per cent voter turnout may come through for him as those who have decided to choose Anwar continue to throng polling centres this afternoon amidst heavy rain. After all, many of them have shown a similar fighting spirit throughout the nightly ceramahs despite the downpours.

Voting ends today at 5pm and results are expected as early as 7pm.