Topics in this digest:
1. Indonesia defied doomsayers to become a surprise success story
1. Indonesia defied doomsayers to become a surprise success story
Posted by: "jip_id" email@example.com jip_id
Date: Tue Mar 9, 2010 4:06 pm ((PST))
Indonesia defied doomsayers to become a surprise success story
Today at 06:40 | Edit note | Delete
March 9, 2010
Many countries are going badly. Indonesia was always going to be one. Or so we thought. It's turned out to be one of the surprise success stories.
For Australia, Indonesia was always the dark zone of dread, where bad things happened with worse to come. This wasn't entirely baseless. Soekarno's communist demagoguery was real. The brutal repressiveness of Soeharto's military dictatorship was no figment of the imagination. But when Soeharto's regime fell and the Indonesian economy collapsed simultaneously in 1998, it seemed to be the worst-case scenario.
A new Indonesia, the child of chaos and violence, was supposed to arise. These were the dominant scenarios that Australian Indonesia-watchers sketched out, usually in private, sometimes in public.
The first fear was that without a strong man to hold it together, Indonesia would break up. It would Balkanise, creating a group of fractious, needy, or hostile new countries to our north.
Some Indonesians, watching Australia's sponsorship of East Timor's move to independence, suspected it was unstated policy to encourage a fragmentation. On the contrary. It was never Canberra's policy, but it was one of Canberra's paranoias.
That was the fear. The fact: under the President, Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, universally known as SBY, the most virulent separatist movement, in Aceh, has been reconciled. The West Papuan independence movement is moribund. The country is unified and stable. East Timor was the only breakaway, and its sad stagnation has not inspired imitators.
The second big fear was that without a military dictator to repress fundamentalist Islam, Indonesia would turn radical.
Perhaps the Islamists would take control through the ballot box. Perhaps the Islamic extremists would revive the Darul Islam project to overthrow the government violently and impose fundamentalist sharia law. Either way, Indonesia would become a brooding presence, increasingly hostile to Western values and inimical to Australian interests.
The fact: as the Australian National University's Greg Fealy wrote after last year's legislative elections: "Despite the fact that almost 90 per cent of the electorate is Muslim, Islamic parties gained less than 30 per cent of the vote - their lowest figure over the three democratic elections held after the downfall of President Soeharto in 1998."
This doesn't mean Indonesians are abandoning Islam. There is a trend to increasing religious observance. A growing percentage are attending prayers, fasting during Ramadan, and using Islamic banks. Muslims pursue their religious beliefs as a personal, social and religious matter, not a political one. Voters demand better services from their government, not religious exhortation.
Other religions, including its Christian churches, are flourishing too. In the immediate post-Soeharto years, churches were firebombed in an effort to foment sectarian upheaval. In an interesting role reversal, it's in next-door Malaysia that churches are under attack. In Indonesia, religious tolerance is practised and the secular state is increasingly entrenched.
A relapse into military dictatorship was the third scenario. A new-generation general would assert control. Perhaps he'd be provoked by an Islamist uprising, by the break-up of the nation, or by political disarray.
The fact: Indonesia today is led by a former general, but he was chosen by the people in a free election, not just once, but now for a second term. SBY is a model democrat.
The only generals who vie for power do so at the ballot box. They campaign for votes like other candidates do, often singing ballads at rallies to woo voters rather than ordering the troops to intimidate them.
Democracy is entrenched as the sole source of legitimacy. The media is one of the world's most thrusting and free, and strong democratic institutions are increasingly solid. Corruption remains a serious problem, but the polity is struggling mightily to break its grip.
Neighbouring Thailand has relapsed into military coups. In Indonesia, the generals are in the barracks and no one in Jakarta speaks of coups any more.
Fourth was the fear that massive economic dislocation and political unrest would precipitate a torrent of Indonesian boat people. In a country of 230 million, it was often pointed out, you'd only need 1 per cent to head for the boats and Australia's systems would be overwhelmed.
The fact: the economic and political upheaval came and went. The boat people? None came. Refugees from Afghanistan, Sri Lanka and other countries have, via Indonesia, but the Indonesians stayed home. They are pretty happy where they are.
Since the trauma of the Asian economic crisis in 1998, Indonesia's economy has developed better than almost anyone could have imagined. In the crisis, one-seventh of the Indonesian economy evaporated, while interest rates shot up to 75 per cent. But its average for the past five years is 5 per cent a year, behind only China and India among the region's economies.
The World Bank recently said Indonesia has a ''unique opportunity to rise as a dynamic, inclusive, middle-income country which can be both a leading sophisticated commodity economy like Australia [and] a hub of labour-intensive industry in Asia like China".
The final fear was that Indonesia would be an impenetrable haven for terrorists, who would launch operations against Australia at will. Indonesia was so riddled with Islamist extremists, and the Indonesian state so weak and incompetent, Australia would have to live in a permanent state of terrorist siege.
The fact: there have been terrorist attacks against Australian citizens and interests, including the Bali bombing. The threat remains real. But the Indonesian authorities, in co-operation with Australian counterparts, have proved to be vigorous and highly effective counter-terrorists.
For all of these reasons, the Australian Parliament tomorrow recognises Indonesia's emergence as a moderate, stable, peaceful, secular democracy, and it honours Yudhoyono as the pivot on which it has turned, when he addresses a joint sitting.
Peter Hartcher is the Sydney Morning Herald's international editor.
Messages in this topic (1)
2. Dunia-Politik.blogspot.com : Artikel Blog, Berita & Web Politik - 03
Posted by: "firstname.lastname@example.org" email@example.com pdniaga
Date: Tue Mar 9, 2010 4:39 pm ((PST))
Dunia-Politik.blogspot.com: Artikel Blog, Berita & Web Politik - 03 Hingga
09 March 2010
1. Pak Lah anggap BN belum kuat walau beberapa MP PKR keluar parti
2. Small is beautiful: Japan's hand-made electric cars
3. 'Guarded communities' to get ministry guidelines
4. Taiwan hit by 6.4 magnitude earthquake
5. Choi eyes the Malaysian carrot
6. Who speaks for Islam?
7. Picket at M'sin Embassy, London & Open Letter to Najib. Open letter
to Prime Minister of Malaysia, Najib Tun Razak.
8. Anwar tak layak Ketua Pembangkang
9. Relief as fish supplies resume at border
10. Hadi Awang setuju dengan GERRYMANDERING !
11. 12 PKR MPs pledge loyalty to kill rumours
12. Konsep Kebebasan Kehakiman
13. Rencana BH kena batang hidung pemimpin Umno
14. MYSTERY: Jaringan Anwar dengan Yahudi dan Mossad (Bhg1)
15. LAWATAN TAPAK UITM CADANGAN DAN KELOLAAN YBK
16. Budak 18 bulan mati dipukul, dipijak jiran
17. US will restore aid to Honduras
18. Surat Umi Hafilda kepada Perdana Menteri
19. Northern Korean colonel tells all
20. Gambar Penuh Majlis Sambutan Maulidur Rasul 1431H di Kediaman Rasmi MB
21. The price of speaking up
22. Memecah gejala politik fobia rakyat, antara obligasi Pakatan Rakyat
23. But Zul, non-Muslims too voted for you...
24. Wan Azizah: Zul must decide his future in PKR
25. Lompat: Pengundi PR diseru buat laporan polis
26. Pengundi Bagan Serai Desak Mohsin Letak Jawatan
27. Not at all sexed-up
28. Tazkirah Jumaat: Kritik dan Pujian. Bagaimana Penerimaan Anda?
29. PENGUMUMAN PENTING DARI YAYASAN BASMI KEMISKINAN! JAWAPAN ISU-ISU
TANAH YANG DIBANGKIT OLEH KERAJAAN NEGERI SELANGOR
30. KALID GAGAP VS YBK : KASIHANILAH NASIB ANAK YATIM INI (SIRI 1)
31. Death in custody No. 1805 : Report on Day 4 of Gunasegaran's inquest
32. MYSTERY: Khalid mahu tukar YBK jadi YAYASAN BANTU KEADILAN?
33. DI BAWAH KOPIAH PUTIHNYA DIPENUHI NAJIS
34. MYSTERY: Nora Reformasi dah sedia jual 'body' untuk reformasi II
35. GIMIK PKR : KELUAR PARTI DILABEL SAMPAH!
36. Khalid Ibrahim is NIZAR II? YBK worm coming out slowly
37. RPK speaks his mind - 17th episode
38. 1 maut, 10 cedera polis bertempur dengan militan
39. PERKUATKAN KETAHANAN , MP PKR AKAN DITARBIAH - ANWAR
40. Zulkifli tak hirau dipecat
41. YB Zul! Hang joint AKIM saja la...
42. Pelancaran Sekretariat Wanita PR Perak: Perasmian oleh Dato Seri Haji
43. Between the devil and deep blue sea lies 'third force'
44. MCA perlu segera selesai masalah pemilihan parti: Muhyiddin
45. Nothing personal, Anwar tells Zul
46. Anwar Pecat Zul Nordin..ada cerita sensasi bakal meletup ?
47. Tepaktaklaku cerca Parpu kutuk Kuda Jew!
48. Kenyataan Anwar tentang Zulkifli Nordin
49. Debat kalimah Allah - Taib Azamuddin
50. Kalimah Allah Hak Kristian - Anwar
51. Zulkifli Nordin Dirujuk Kepada Lembaga Disiplin PKR
52. Kenapa Anwar berguru dengan Orientalis?
53. Anwar Ibrahim disanjung oleh Majlis Gereja
54. Anwar Ibrahim bertegas kalimah 'Allah' hak Kristian
55. Pakatan Rakyat: Jual Kalimah 'Allah' Untuk Beli Undi Kristian?
56. Anwar meets Christians to defuse tension
57. BEZA FOKUS ?
58. PANAS! PANAS! SI KITOL CUBA MENCARI TALIAN HAYAT!
59. Parpukari berharga sepinggan Nasi Kandar segelas teh tarik aja ~ aduh
buat kotor blog aku saja
60. Dua sarjana Amerika sokong Anwar
61. Pupuk Tradisi Ilmiah, Bukan Sikap Bebal
62. Menembusi polemik Ali Abdul Raziq
63. MCA pecah 3 kumpulan menjelang pemilihan 28 Mac ini.
64. Pas Tidak Mungkin Berbaik Dengan UMNO - TGNA
65. Mufti Perak Bidas Nik Aziz!
66. Sin Chew Jit Poh tunjuk sifat cauvanis Cina yang ketara
67. Abhisit cancels Australia trip
68. SIN CHEW JIT POH MEMPERSENDA 76 NGO MELAYU MENGIGAU DAN BERKHAYAL
69. 7 NGO CINA DISERU MENUMBANGKAN KERAJAAN
70. RAKYAT MALAYSIA: MISKIN BERTAMBAH MISKIN, KAYA SEMAKIN KAYA -
71. 2011 - Melayu Tumpas?
72. Guan Eng rides the tiger
73. MCA to continue to seek recognition for UEC
74. Corat-coret dari Dewan Negara
75. KEMISKINAN, PADANG PERMAINAN YANG RATA & KESAMARATAAN
76. Apa Kita Mahu?
77. Umno / BN akan tumpas?
78. Melayu dikhianati?
79. 1Malaysia : Bukan Melayu Perlu Ikhlas
80. KAKI DALAM KASUT
81. DAP bermain api
82. Piagam Madinah
83. UMNO, Pas ada persamaan
84. Nik Aziz tidak ikhlas jalin kerjasama
85. NATIONAL UNITY - OUR ELUSIVE DREAM
86. KABINET YAB DATO' SRI NAJIB - SIAPA SENYUM; SIAPA MENANGIS?
87. Sektor perkhidmatan diliberalisasi
88. Liberalisasi kewangan
89. Modenisasi sektor awam
90. PNB menganak-tirikan bumi?
91. Anutan anak ibu bapa tukar agama kekal
92. Hukum syarak penentu status agama anak
93. Majlis berhemah
94. Struggle for the soul of Umno
95. Level playing field
96. Make 1Malaysia more than mere slogan
97. KENYATAAN AKHBAR
98. Liberalisasi beri fleksibiliti
99. Masyarakat Perdagangan dan Perindustrian Bumiputera (MPPB) - Siapa
Mereka / Di Mana Mereka?
100. 'Saya tidak akan berterima kasih'
101. Divisive politics taking shape
102. Karpal: PAS Dewan Ulama's call not good for
103. Polemik tukar agama anak
104. Changes aplenty in the works
105. State stand on religion ruling, DAP told
106. The Star had compared Pak Lah with the destroyer
107. Statement On Apartheid Aims To Get More Power
108. Nik Aziz says 'bumiputera' term is racist
109. Jangan biadap, titah Sultan
110. New censorship guidelines to allow local
movie-makers more flexibility
111. Bruni tak pakai coli tarik perhatian
112. Chinese medium schools to the rescue
113. Tiga beradik rentung rumah terbakar di Bukit
114. PENDEDAHAN - SELANGOR SELEPAS 2 TAHUN DI BAWAH
PEMERINTAHAN PAKATAN HARAM! HANCUSS!
115. Kad Laporan 2 tahun PR Selangor - GAGAL!
116. Mari lihat kembali janji Pakatan dan apa
pulangan yang kita dapat hari ini
117. DSAI at Selangor PR Anniversary Celebration
118. CHARITY BEGINS WITH THE VOTERS
119. PM slammed for chickening out on new economic
120. Jakim denies caning violates women's rights
121. APABILA YB ZUL UNGKIT JASA BELIAU TERHADAP KAK
122. 62.4 peratus keluar mengundi pilihan raya Iraq
123. Rosmah Mansor: Will she? Won't she?
124. The brewing storm of GST
125. Perutusan anti-UG & genap 2 tahun Pakatan Rakyat
memerintah oleh TGNA
126. Do we still need Jambatan Bengkok?
127. Kebajingan si kitul beruk itam penuntut setia
pelenjan bontot jantan.
128. Harussani jadi agen Umno?
Dunia-Politik.blogspot.com - Artikel Blog, Berita & Web Politik - 03 Hingga 09 March 2010.pdf
Messages in this topic (1)
Ahli yang menghantar menggunakan kata-kata kesat dan kasar atau menyerang peribadi ahli yang lain, email mereka tidak akan disiarkan.
Ahli group yang sentiasa menghantar email berkenaan politik sahaja akan disiarkan emailnya tanpa penapisan moderator group.
Email yang disiarkan dipertanggungjawabkan kepada pengirim email tersebut dimana moderator dan group tidak boleh dipertanggungjawabkan.
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
<*> Your email settings:
Digest Email | Traditional
<*> To change settings online go to:
(Yahoo! ID required)
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: